Manuel Milan/iStock Editorial by using Getty Images

Soon after initiation of protection with a invest in score in Volkswagen AG (OTCPK: VWAGY) (OTCPK: VLKAF) (OTC: VWAPY), today we deliver a deep-dive analysis of Renault (OTC:RNSDF, OTCPK:RNLSY) commenting on its Q4 and FY 2021 and seeking at what appears to be the most exposed car or truck automaker in Russia. In advance of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, we were being not beneficial on Renault and we have been on the lookout at the French automaker as a ‘exhibit me story‘. At this time, with a inventory price that fell far more than 30% surpassing the decline of its total Russian current market, we firmly believe that that management groups will need to have to clearly show the investor group some positive success, specifically pertaining to profitability. Even if the turnaround circumstance is very persuasive and provided the fact that Renault is at present trading at the most affordable many in contrast to its peers, we initiate coverage with a neutral ranking and a concentrate on rate of 25 euros per share.

Renault stock price 1Y evolution

Renault inventory selling price 1Y evolution

Q4 and FY 2021 Effects

Luca De Meo’s treatment is bearing some fruits. Renault returned to earnings in 2021 with a web outcome of €967 million, many thanks in distinct to an improve in its income prices. Right after a incredibly complicated 2020 and even with the semiconductor scarcity, the team recorded income of €46.2 billion in 2021, up by 6.3% in comparison to the prior year’s conclusion. The group’s functioning margin of 3.6% also exceeded its anticipations. It had earlier aimed for an working margin at the very same stage of 2.8% recorded in the initial 50 % of the yr so the Renaulution purpose of an operating margin of extra than 3% in 2023 has been realized 2 several years in progress. Web income were in optimistic territory adopted by the former year’s losses of €8.01 billion and a reduction of €141 million registered in 2019. Even if the money stream was constructive the team has resolved to not propose any dividend payments for 2021.

Other Renaulution goals accomplished in progress ended up:

  1. Fixed cost reduction of €2 billion in contrast to 2019 that was applied a single year in progress
  2. Reduction of the breakeven level by 40% compared to 2019, carried out 2 a long time in progress
  3. Usefulness of the new professional plan that favours worth more than volumes (5.7 basis place extra when compared the 2020 benefits)
  4. Development of the Team purchase reserve in Europe with about 3 months of sales supported by the attractiveness of the Renault E-TECH choices
  5. Products blend improvement and fleet enrichment, in certain with the start of the Renault Mégane E-TECH Electric powered, Renault Austral and Dacia Jogger.

Renault 2021 Financial results

Renault 2021 Economical final results

Russian direct and indirect publicity

At the time of its FY launch, inspite of a context that was still impacted by the semiconductor crisis and by the uncooked content value raises, Renault had estimated to maximize its running margin to at least 4% and to deliver automotive functioning funds flows of at least €1 billion. Due to the fact the Russian invasion, the French automaker has approved the next:

  • Renault’s Russian pursuits have been suspended
  • Regarding its stake in AVTOVAZ which is entirely consolidated as a JV (as it owns ~67%), the French car producer is assessing several solutions.

Renault Team has obligation for much more than 45K staff in Russia. Because of to that, Renault Group has to revise its 2022 financial advice with:

  1. Running margin of all-around 3% (vs . the prior sign of ≥ 4%)
  2. A good automotive operating absolutely free money stream (as opposed to the past indicator of ≥ €1Bn).

We generally do not remark on politics but it is crucial to report some info: “French firms should depart the Russian industry” Ukrainian President Zelenskyy announced in a video handle, criticising Renault and other people for “sponsoring the Russian war equipment.” We remind our viewers that the French point out owns a 15% stake in Renault Group.

Politics apart and likely to the figures, we see that the Russian sector is the 2nd major market place for Renault and it accounts for more than 10% of its overall gross sales. What’s critical to observe is that pretty much 40% of Russian auto creation is (or it’s possible was?) in Renault’s palms. In 1 of the final studies posted by the French automobile maker, we see that Russia has been named 53 instances. Having checked the report, we estimate that Russia’s revenue account for €5 billion and operating revenue stood at €300 million.

Out of curiosity, you can check out out the online video of Renault’s plant in the area.

Renault Moscow Plan main products

Renault Moscow Prepare principal products and solutions

Conclusion and Valuation

In contrast to the other European gamers, Renault is less diversified at a geographical level, and we think that soon after the 23 March announcement, Renault will completely write down its Russian assets that accounted for €2.2 billion. Because February 23 (up right now), the market capitalisation that has been shed is a lot greater than its Russian equity stake. Even so, we are thinking if the inventory price tag adjustment has been much too intense.

Our internal staff was positively impressed by the new management team and by the small business advancement noted in its Q4 and FY effects. Sadly, wartime, geo/automobile exposure, and new assistance favour other OEMs these kinds of as Volkswagen.

If you are fascinated in our hottest automotive protection, please have a appear at:

  1. Volkswagen: All About The Lengthy-Term Developments
  2. Ferrari To RACE Once again

By Tara